Antibiotic audit tool options for stewardship teams and the data each audit needs
An antibiotic audit tool checks whether each prescription had an indication, the right empiric drug, a 72 hour review and a stop date. Here is what each kind of tool can and cannot check, what it costs, and the one input most audits get wrong.
8 min read
An antibiotic audit tool is whatever a stewardship team uses to review prescriptions against a standard and feed the result back to prescribers. It ranges from a two page chart form to a module inside a clinical surveillance platform. The choice depends on how many charts you review, who reviews them, and whether the tool can check the empiric drug against your own hospital's current susceptibility data, which is the criterion most audits handle worst.
This comparison is for the stewardship pharmacist or infectious diseases physician setting up or scaling a prospective audit and feedback program at a community hospital. Every vendor is described from its own published material. Antimicrobe is not an audit tool, and the article says exactly where it fits: it produces the local antibiogram the audit uses as its reference.
What an antibiotic stewardship audit tool has to check
Most audit forms, from US state programs to the English Start Smart then Focus toolkit, check the same handful of criteria. The CDC Core Elements of Hospital Antibiotic Stewardship Programs name prospective audit and feedback as one of the two priority interventions, and every audit tool is really a way of applying these criteria at volume.
| Audit criterion | Data the reviewer needs | Where that data lives |
|---|---|---|
| Indication documented | Order and progress notes | EHR |
| Cultures sent before the first dose | Collection time and administration time | Lab system and eMAR |
| Empiric agent fits local guidance | Current local percent susceptible for the likely organism | Hospital antibiogram |
| Review or time-out at 48 to 72 hours | Documentation of the review | EHR |
| Narrowed to culture result | Final susceptibility for this patient | Lab system |
| IV to oral switch when eligible | Route, diet, vital signs | EHR and eMAR |
| Duration and stop date set | Order end date | EHR |
Antibiotic audit tool options side by side
There are four kinds of tool in use in US hospitals. They differ mostly in how the patient list is produced and where the reviewer records the intervention, not in the criteria, which are largely the same.
| Option | Builds the patient list | Records interventions | Checks against local antibiogram | Price published |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper or spreadsheet chart audit form | No, reviewer pulls charts | On the form | Only if the reviewer has a current antibiogram | Usually free from public health bodies |
| General checklist and inspection apps | No | Yes, as a checklist | No | Per user subscription |
| EHR stewardship module (for example Epic) | Yes, rule based worklist | Yes | Only if someone maintains the rules | Part of the EHR contract |
| Surveillance platforms (Sentri7, VigiLanz, TheraDoc) | Yes, real-time alerts | Yes, with reports | Partly, through configured rules | No, quoted after demo |
| Antimicrobe | No | No | Produces the antibiogram the audit uses | Yes, from $249 a month |
Which antibiotic audit tool fits a community hospital
If the team reviews 20 to 40 charts a month, a structured form and a spreadsheet are enough to start, and the cost is the reviewer's time. The limit appears when the program wants every patient on a target drug reviewed within 72 hours. At that point the patient list has to be generated, not hunted for, and that is what an EHR stewardship module or a surveillance platform sells. The Epic route and what its stewardship worklist does is covered in Epic antimicrobial stewardship module, and the platforms are compared in Sentri7 vs TheraDoc vs VigiLanz.
Platform pricing is not published, so budget conversations start late. The known facts about each quote are collected on Sentri7 pricing and in clinical surveillance software for small hospitals, which also shows which half of a platform a smaller hospital can price today.
The audit criterion most tools get wrong
The empiric choice criterion asks whether the first antibiotic fit local guidance. That guidance is only as current as the antibiogram behind it. Many community hospitals still build the antibiogram by hand once a year, sometimes later, and the audit then measures conformity to a table that may be two or three years old. A high concordance rate looks like success when it may mean everyone is following stale advice.
Surveillance platforms partly solve this by building rules from recent results, but the rules are configured once and drift. Chart forms do not solve it at all; the reviewer is told to compare with "local guidance" and usually has a PDF on the intranet. The fix is upstream of the audit tool: a current cumulative antibiogram, built to CLSI M39 with first isolates per patient, that the guidance and the audit both point at.
A worked example of an empiric choice audit
A 120 bed hospital audits 40 adults admitted with pyelonephritis over one quarter. Local guidance, written from an antibiogram built three years ago, recommends ceftriaxone, because E. coli urine isolates were then 94 percent susceptible. The audit finds 31 of 40 patients started on ceftriaxone, 77.5 percent concordance, and the committee sets a target of 85 percent.
Now rebuild the antibiogram from the last 12 months of the lab export. After the first isolate rule, 412 E. coli urine isolates remain and 358 are ceftriaxone susceptible, 86.9 percent. On the unit that admits most nursing home residents, the figure is 71 of 93, 76.3 percent. The audit question changes: several of the 9 non-concordant prescribers may have been right to choose differently, and the guidance needs a separate recommendation for patients from long-term care. The audit tool did its job, and the data behind it was the weak point. These figures are illustrative arithmetic, not data from a customer.
How much does an antibiotic audit tool cost?
Chart audit forms published by public health bodies cost nothing but reviewer time, which at 15 to 20 minutes a chart adds up quickly. EHR stewardship modules are licensed as part of the EHR, plus analyst time to build and maintain rules. Surveillance platforms are quoted per organization after a demo, typically as an implementation fee plus an annual license. Whichever route you choose, the audit still needs a current antibiogram, and Antimicrobe builds that from a lab CSV export from $249 a month, with unit cuts on the $749 Stewardship plan. Plans are on the pricing page, and a full budget for a small program is in antibiotic stewardship software cost for a small hospital.
What should an antibiotic stewardship audit report include?
A useful audit report shows the number of charts reviewed, concordance with each criterion, the interventions recommended and how many were accepted, and the local susceptibility figures the empiric criterion was judged against, with the date of the antibiogram. Including that date makes stale guidance visible. The metrics a committee usually tracks next to audit results are listed in antibiotic stewardship metrics, and the hospital-wide table itself is described on hospital antibiogram software.
- Charts reviewed and the selection method
- Concordance per criterion, not one overall score
- Interventions recommended, accepted and declined
- The antibiogram date and the percent susceptible used for the empiric criterion
- Unit or service where non-concordance clusters
Where Antimicrobe fits
Antimicrobe does not build a patient worklist, record interventions or read the EHR. It builds the cumulative antibiogram, unit and source cuts and quarterly resistance trends from your laboratory's susceptibility export, so the empiric criterion in any audit tool points at numbers from the last 12 months instead of a three year old PDF. The cuts that matter most for urinary and ICU audits are on urine antibiogram and UTI resistance rates and ICU antibiogram software. If the budget line says monitoring rather than audit, the difference between tracking antibiotic use and tracking resistance is explained in antimicrobial monitoring software for hospitals.
Related on this site: antibiotic stewardship program software, empiric antibiotic therapy by local susceptibility, clinical surveillance software for small hospitals.